Free Business Growth Consultation — Limited spots available
RankConvert

GOODNYT Shopify Store Audit: CRO Fixes for a Clean Store That Scored 6/10

GOODNYT’s store looks great but scored 6 out of 10 in our audit. Here are the CRO fixes it needs, and what to check on yours.

Jake MarlerJake MarlerOct 9, 20268 min read
GOODNYT Shopify Store Audit: CRO Fixes for a Clean Store That Scored 6/10
On this page

    TL;DR: We audited GOODNYT, an Australian combat sports brand running on Shopify, and scored the store 6 out of 10. The design, branding and photography are clean, but the store is missing the conversion fundamentals: no reviews or proof above the fold, no FAQs or shipping information on the homepage, a best sellers link that leads to an empty page, no SEO copy on collection pages, and thin product descriptions with no bundle offer. Fixing those would lift trust, conversion rate and average order value without changing how the site looks.

    Key takeaways
    6.5/10
    Hero section
    7/10
    Homepage
    6/10
    Collection page
    6/10
    Product page
    6/10
    Overall
    ✓Clean design, weak conversion. Branding and photography are strong. The CRO fundamentals are what is missing.
    ✓No proof above the fold. Add a review rating or pro athlete credentials to the hero section.
    ✓Homepage gaps. Label the best sellers, fix the empty best sellers link, add FAQs, shipping and returns.
    ✓Collection pages need SEO. Add a keyword intro, related collection shortcuts and an information section at the bottom.
    ✓Product pages need detail. Add three to five benefit dot points, reviews and shipping, returns and warranty dropdowns.
    ✓Lift order value. Offer a discount on a second pair, with free shipping, right on the product page.

    Watch the full GOODNYT Shopify store audit

    Hero section: 6.5 out of 10

    GOODNYT sells boxing, Muay Thai and MMA gear alongside streetwear. The first thing you see is a cracking photo with the line “Australian owned. Thai crafted. Engineered for combat.” and two buttons: Shop Combat and Shop Streetwear. For context on the scores, five is average, so 6.5 is a good result.

    An optimised ecommerce hero section needs five things, and this one has about half of them:

    • A strong hero image. Tick. The photography across the whole store is excellent.
    • A heading that sells the emotion. “Engineered for combat” does the job. Something like “Upgrade your striking game” would lean even harder into the benefit.
    • A subheading that gives the logic. Missing. This is where you say exactly what the store is, for example “Australian combat store. High quality Thai-made gloves, gear and apparel.”
    • Proof above the fold. Missing. Unless you are a household name, people need a reason to trust you before they scroll.
    • Buttons that pop. The labels are clear, but the button colour blends in with the rest of the page.

    Anatomy of a high-converting Shopify hero section: hero image, emotional heading, logical subheading, proof and a contrasting button

    How to add proof when you are a newer store

    If you have 600 five-star reviews or 10,000 products sold, say so. If you are new and only have a handful of reviews, leave the number out. “Five-star rated by Australian combat athletes” is still true, and it names the exact people you are selling to. A shopper reads it and thinks “people like me rate this”.

    GOODNYT also features Australian MMA fighters in its hero carousel, but never says who they are. Adding a name and “professional MMA athlete” under each one turns a nice photo into a credibility signal.

    Button colour

    Your main buttons should complement your brand colours but contrast with them, so they are the first thing the eye lands on. Getting people to click those buttons is the whole reason the page exists.

    Homepage: 7 out of 10

    It is a good homepage with strong branding. A handful of fixes would move it up quickly.

    goodnyt combat wear

    What works

    • Products straight after the hero. Best sellers belong directly under the hero because they are the products most likely to sell.
    • Collection tiles. The Shop Combat and Shop Apparel category sections are clear and the photos are great.
    • An about section. “The NYT difference” explains who they are. This also helps with AI search: when an AI tool crawls your homepage, a clear description of who you are and what you sell makes it easier to recommend you.
    • Blog posts. “The Locker Room” is good for SEO.

    What to fix

    • Add headings to the product sections. The first product row has no heading. Tell people they are looking at best sellers.
    • Use tabs. Gymshark and other top stores put tabs on this section, so shoppers can flick between best sellers, new arrivals and the top two to four categories without leaving the page.
    • Use a carousel, not a grid. A grid keeps expanding down the page. A carousel shows the same products in a fraction of the space.
    • Fix the best sellers link. It leads to a page with no products, and another link returned a 404. Either add products to the collection or remove the button. Dead ends make a brand look unprofessional.
    • Keep hover photos consistent. The second image that shows on hover should follow the same style across every product.
    • Add FAQs. Every homepage should have them. It is an easy win.
    • Show your athletes. If credible fighters use the gear, give them their own section in the top half of the page.
    • Add shipping, returns and selling points. Free shipping over $80 and 30-day returns are on the product page but nowhere on the homepage.

    Sell the problem, then the solution

    One more thing the homepage could do is name the problem. Cheap gloves from a random store are itchy and scratchy, give you no wrist support, and come with poor customer service. Say that, then show why your gloves are the answer: proper wrist support, high quality materials, great service and a money-back guarantee.

    Problem and solution selling example for an ecommerce homepage

    Collection page: 6 out of 10

    We looked at the boxing gloves collection. It is a little better than average, with some key pieces missing.

    goodnyt boxing gloves collection page

    What works

    • Four products per row. Four is the sweet spot on desktop.
    • Clean filters. Size, product type and price.
    • Sensible collections. Separate pages for boxing gloves, MMA gloves and Muay Thai gloves, plus an overall gloves page.

    What to fix

    • Add an intro under the heading. One or two sentences with “boxing gloves” in the first sentence.
    • Add related collection shortcuts. Gymshark puts small photo links to related collections at the top of each collection page. Here that would be MMA gloves, Muay Thai gloves and all gloves. It helps shoppers move around and gives Google clear internal links.
    • Add an information section at the bottom. A text section answering questions like “what size boxing gloves should I wear?” and “how do I wash boxing gloves?” helps the page rank.
    • Fix the badge colours. The “new” badges are black and blend in. Use a colour hierarchy so badges stand out.
    • Add a quick add to cart. There is no way to add a product from the collection page.
    • Show review stars. Once reviews come in, show the rating on each product tile.
    • Add authority points. Short lines like “handmade in Thailand” near the top of the page.

    Ecommerce SEO: where your keyword needs to appear

    When you optimise a page for a search term, the keyword should show up in a few specific places: the H1, the first sentence under it, at least one H2, the body text, an image file name, an image alt text, the meta title and the meta description.

    GOODNYT has the H1 and not much else on its collection pages. This is the foundation of ecommerce SEO: every collection page targets one search term and uses it in each of these spots, backed by the intro copy and information section covered above.

    SEO keyword placement checklist for a Shopify collection page

    Product page: 6 out of 10

    The product page is cleanly designed, like the rest of the store. It is missing the details that raise conversion rate and order value.

    goodnyt muay thai gloves product page

    What works

    • High quality photos. They even include infographic-style photos, which most stores skip.
    • A size guide. Right next to the size options.
    • Trust points near the button. Free shipping over $80, 30-day easy returns, and tested by fighters.

    What to fix

    • Rebalance the photos. Around three lifestyle photos is enough. Use the rest of the gallery for more infographic photos.
    • Tighten the layout. The size guide pop-up should fill the screen instead of making you scroll sideways, and the trust points should fit on one line.
    • Add dot points to the description. Three to five dot points on why the product is good, near the top.
    • Add reviews. There are none yet, and they are always powerful.
    • Add dropdowns for shipping, returns and warranty. So people can read the detail without leaving the page.
    • Add more information sections. With a small range, there is room to cover the materials and benefits of each product properly.
    • Fix the broken link. One of the recommended links on the product page returned a 404.

    Add a bundle offer

    A viral MMA glove brand we compared in the video does something smart on its product page: add a second pair and get 30% off it, mix boxing and MMA gloves, and get free shipping. GOODNYT sells boxing, MMA and Muay Thai gloves, so an offer like this is a natural fit and an easy way to lift average order value.

    yibuko-boxing-gloves-bundle-quantity-selector

    The final score: 6 out of 10

    The design is clean, the photos are clean and the brand styling is clean. What is missing are the fundamentals that help people trust the store, understand why they should buy, and feel comfortable checking out.

    GOODNYT Shopify store audit scorecard: hero section 6.5, homepage 7, collection page 6, product page 6, overall 6 out of 10

    What Shopify developers would fix first on this store

    None of these fixes need a redesign. As Melbourne Shopify developers, this is the order we would work through them, starting with the quickest wins:

    • Fix the empty best sellers collection and the 404 links
    • Add proof and a subheading to the hero section
    • Add shipping, returns and FAQs to the homepage
    • Add benefit dot points and policy dropdowns to every product page
    • Add a second pair bundle offer to the glove product pages
    • Add intro copy, related collection shortcuts and an information section to every collection page

    The conversion rate optimisation lesson for your own store

    A good looking store is not the same as a store that converts. GOODNYT has done the hard part, which is building a brand people want to buy from. Conversion rate optimisation is the less exciting work that sits on top of that: proof, clear information, working links and offers that raise the order value. If your store looks great but the numbers are flat, this is usually where the gap is.

    Want your store audited?

    If you would like a breakdown like this for your own store, drop your URL in the comments on the YouTube video and we will add it to the list.

    Share
    Jake Marler
    Written by

    Jake Marler

    Founder, RankConvert

    Jake helps Melbourne businesses turn their websites into reliable growth engines through SEO, conversion-focused design and Shopify optimisation.

    SEOShopifyCROMelbourne
    View profile
    Google Reviews5.0

    Ready to Scale Your Business Online?

    Feeling lost in the digital landscape? You're not alone. Many business owners struggle to leverage online platforms effectively, missing out on the growth potential that exists outside their traditional market spaces. At RankConvert, we specialize in transforming your digital presence into a strategic growth engine. Our proven techniques empower you to connect with your audience genuinely, optimizing every stage of their journey. Reach out today, and together we can unlock new revenue streams for your business.

    No lock-in contractsFree strategy callAustralian owned & operated
    Link copied